Supreme pizza with sausage, peppers, and olives on a dark table at Tony Pepperoni in Henrietta NY

Rochester's Favorite

Pizza, Wings& Subs

Serving up pizza, wings, calzones, salads, dinners and subs to RIT, MCC, local businesses and Henrietta Residents since 2003!

Order Online View Our Menu Call To Order

View the Full MenuPizzas, wings, subs, dinners, salads & more — all in one place

Dine In

Relax and enjoy your meal with us

Takeout

Call ahead or order online

Delivery

Get your favorites delivered to your door

Catering Available

Pizza, Wings, Subs & More for Your Next Event

Get a Catering Quote

Warmly lit dining room tables at the Tony Pepperoni pizzeria in Henrietta NY

A Henrietta Tradition

Pizza · Wings · Submarines · Dinners · Salads

Cheese, pepperoni, and veggie pizzas on display at the Tony Pepperoni pizzeria counter in Henrietta NY

Our Story

Love pizza? So do we

Tony Pepperoni started in 2003 when three brothers had a vision of opening a pizzeria that prided itself on quality food at an affordable price. We opened and maintained our personal vision and are proud of the food and service we dish out on a daily basis. Our dedication to our craft and commitment to ensuring customer satisfaction is evident in our high-quality food and friendly atmosphere.

Try our delicious wings (best in town), hot and cold subs on fresh-baked bread, specialty salads, calzones and more. Our menu has something for everyone.

Why We're the Catered Choice in Henrietta & Rochester, NY

At Tony Pepperoni, we're more than just a local pizza shop — we're the crew that businesses, teams, and event organizers call when they need great food delivered on time. For over 25 years, we've been proudly feeding the Henrietta and greater Rochester community with pizza, wings, calzones, subs, and salads that always hit the spot.

Takeout bowl of penne pasta with meatballs and marinara — catering from Tony Pepperoni Henrietta NY

Chef salad in a takeout container packed for catering delivery in Rochester NY

Platter of buffalo chicken wings with celery and dip — party tray catering in Henrietta NY

Pepperoni pizza party tray ready for catering pickup at Tony Pepperoni

Local & Reliable
We're right here in the heart of Henrietta — just minutes from RIT, MCC, Marketplace Mall, and nearby hotels. Our location means faster delivery, hotter food, and fewer headaches when you're coordinating meals.
Built for Big Orders
From boardroom lunches to tournament days, our team makes ordering easy. With large-format pizzas, party packs, and group-ready extras, we can handle everything from 10 people to 100+ without breaking a sweat. Your order arrives hot, organized, and ready to serve.
Menu Variety Everyone Loves
Pick crowd-pleasers for every taste and dietary need — specialty pizzas, crispy wings, fresh salads, subs, calzones, and gluten-free options. Every item is made fresh with quality ingredients and packaged for easy serving.
25+ Years of Local Trust
We've built our reputation on consistency, friendly service, and the kind of local pride that shows in every meal. From RIT tournaments to neighborhood fundraisers, Tony Pepperoni has been a part of thousands of events across Rochester — and we're proud to keep that tradition going.